Shared vs Exclusive Roofing Leads — Close Rate, Cost Per Job, Real Numbers
Shared roofing leads go to 4 other roofers simultaneously. Here's the real math on close rate, cost per job, and monthly revenue loss.
Shared lead close rate
8–15%
Exclusive close rate
28–40%
Avg shared lead cost
$150–$300
Cost per closed job (shared)
$1,500–$3,750
Shared roofing leads are priced to look affordable. At $150–$300 per lead, the math seems manageable — until you account for close rate. Shared leads close at 8–15% because the homeowner has already spoken to 3–4 other roofers before you call. You are not the first call. You are the fourth.
Run the real math: at 10% close rate, a $200 shared lead costs $2,000 in lead spend per closed job — before your materials, labor, or overhead. A roofing job that nets $3,000 in profit costs $2,000 just to acquire the customer on shared leads. That is a 67% customer acquisition cost on net margin.
Exclusive hub leasing flips the model. A fixed monthly lease covering all leads in your city — no per-lead fees, no competition on every call. At 30% close rate on exclusive leads, cost per acquired job drops to $500–$900 depending on your market. Same revenue, fraction of the acquisition cost.
At 30% close rate: 32 leads → 10 jobs × $9K = $85K/mo. Hub lease: $5,700–$17,100/mo. Net: $76K/mo.
Shared vs Exclusive Roofing Leads — Side by Side
Same city. Same leads. Different model. Here is what changes when you own the market instead of competing for it.
| Factor | Shared Lead Model | Exclusive Hub Model |
|---|---|---|
| Close rate | 8–15% | 28–40% |
| Cost per closed job | $1,500–$3,750 in lead spend | $500–$900 in lease cost |
| Peak season cost | Price spikes 30–50% — you pay more when demand is highest | Fixed monthly rate — surges captured at no extra cost |
| Lead ownership | Shared with 3–5 competitors simultaneously | Exclusively yours — no competing calls |
| Compounding effect | None — each lead is a fresh race against the same competitors | Reviews, referrals, and repeat calls accumulate in your city over time |
| Sales dynamic | Homeowner comparing 4–5 quotes — decision made on price | You are the only contractor called — decision made on trust and expertise |
Close rate benchmarks sourced from industry data. For licensing and contractor standards, see the National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA).
The Shared Lead Math Roofers Never See Until It's Too Late
A $200 roofing lead sounds reasonable until you factor close rate. At 10% close on shared leads, you pay $2,000 in lead costs for every job you close — before materials, labor, or overhead.
Shared lead platforms guarantee nothing. You pay $150–$300 per lead whether you close it or not. Four other roofers got the same lead and the same bill.
Storm season is the most expensive time to buy shared leads — demand spikes drive shared lead prices up 30–50% while close rates drop because every roofer in the market is calling the same homeowners.
Exclusive hub leasing converts the lead cost from a variable per-lead expense into a fixed monthly fee. At 30% close on exclusive leads, your cost per closed job is your lease cost divided by jobs — typically $500–$900 per closed roofing job.
One roofer per city. Every inquiry routes exclusively to you — zero competition.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the true cost per closed job on shared roofing leads?
At a typical 10–15% close rate on shared leads priced at $150–$300 each, your cost per closed job ranges from $1,000 to $3,750 in lead spend alone — before materials, labor, or overhead. Exclusive leads close at 28–40%, bringing cost per acquired job down to $500–$900.
Why do shared roofing leads have such low close rates?
Shared leads go to 3–5 roofers simultaneously. By the time you call, the homeowner has already spoken to competitors. The first contractor to call has a significant advantage — on shared platforms, that is rarely you. Exclusive leads eliminate the race entirely.
How does storm season affect shared roofing lead costs?
Storm events drive shared lead prices up 30–50% as platforms capitalize on demand spikes. Meanwhile, close rates drop because every roofer in the market is chasing the same homeowners. Exclusive hub leaseholders capture every storm inquiry at a fixed cost regardless of demand.
Are shared roofing leads worth it?
At 8–15% close rate, shared roofing leads cost $1,500–$3,750 per closed job in lead spend alone. For most roofing contractors, the math only works on high-ticket jobs at consistent volume. A hub lease at 28–40% close rate reduces cost per acquired job to $500–$900 — making exclusive leads the more profitable model at any sustained volume.
Why do shared roofing leads have a low close rate?
Shared roofing leads are distributed to 3–5 contractors simultaneously. By the time you call, the homeowner has already spoken to competitors. The first contractor to call has the advantage — on shared platforms, that is rarely you. Exclusive leads eliminate the race: you are the only contractor called.
How many leads per month does a roofing hub generate?
A mid-size city roofing hub generates approximately 32 exclusive leads per month — 10 jobs × $9K avg = $85K/mo in potential revenue.
Why is exclusive better than shared?
Shared leads go to 3–5 contractors simultaneously. Exclusive hub leasing means every inquiry routes only to your business — no competition, 2–3× higher close rates.
How do I claim a roofing hub?
Browse available markets, select your city, and start your lease. One roofer per city at all times.
Own Your Roofing Market
Browse available roofing hubs. One roofer per city. Every lead exclusively yours from day one.
Browse Available Roofing Markets →