Shared vs Exclusive HVAC Leads — What the Close Rate Numbers Actually Show
Shared HVAC leads are sold to 3–5 contractors at once. Here's exactly what that costs you in close rate, revenue, and wasted spend.
Shared lead close rate
8–18%
Exclusive close rate
30–45%
Avg shared lead cost
$150–$310
Cost per closed job (shared)
$833–$3,875
HVAC shared leads are sold to 3–5 contractors simultaneously at $150–$310 each. The platform collects that fee from every contractor. The homeowner speaks to all of them. The one who answers fastest — not the one who does the best work — wins the job.
At 12% close rate, a $200 HVAC lead costs $1,667 per closed job in lead spend. On a $1,800 repair job, that is 93% of gross revenue spent acquiring one customer. On a $6,500 replacement, it is a manageable 26% — but replacement leads at that close rate require consistent volume to sustain.
Exclusive hub leasing eliminates the per-lead race. A fixed monthly lease covers every HVAC inquiry in your city. Close rates on exclusive leads average 30–45% because you are the only contractor called. Cost per acquired job drops by 60–70% compared to shared lead buying at scale.
At 30% close rate: 26 leads → 8 jobs × $7K = $52K/mo. Hub lease: $3,840–$11,520/mo. Net: $46K/mo.
Shared vs Exclusive HVAC Leads — Side by Side
Same city. Same leads. Different model. Here is what changes when you own the market instead of competing for it.
| Factor | Shared Lead Model | Exclusive Hub Model |
|---|---|---|
| Close rate | 8–18% | 30–45% |
| Cost per closed job | $833–$3,875 in lead spend | $400–$700 in lease cost |
| Peak season cost | Price spikes 30–50% — you pay more when demand is highest | Fixed monthly rate — surges captured at no extra cost |
| Lead ownership | Shared with 3–5 competitors simultaneously | Exclusively yours — no competing calls |
| Compounding effect | None — each lead is a fresh race against the same competitors | Reviews, referrals, and repeat calls accumulate in your city over time |
| Sales dynamic | Homeowner comparing 4–5 quotes — decision made on price | You are the only contractor called — decision made on trust and expertise |
Close rate benchmarks sourced from industry data. For licensing and contractor standards, see the Air Conditioning Contractors of America (ACCA).
The HVAC Shared Lead Cost Breakdown Contractors Don't Calculate Until It's Too Late
At 12% close rate on $200 HVAC leads, you spend $1,667 in lead costs for every job you close. On a $6,500 replacement job that nets $2,000, you spent 83% of your net profit just acquiring the customer.
HVAC emergency calls — your highest close rate leads — are the most damaged by shared platforms. A homeowner without AC in July calls whoever answers first. On shared leads, 4 other HVAC contractors got the same call at the same moment.
Summer peak season is when shared HVAC lead prices spike most aggressively. The weeks you need leads most are the weeks you pay the most for leads that close the least — because every competitor is calling the same homeowners.
Exclusive hub leasing converts HVAC lead acquisition from an unpredictable per-job expense into a fixed monthly infrastructure cost. You know your cost per month. You know your market. Revenue becomes predictable.
One HVAC contractor per city. Every inquiry routes exclusively to you — zero competition.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does a shared HVAC lead actually cost per closed job?
At a 12% close rate on $200 shared leads, cost per closed job is $1,667 in lead spend. At a 8% close rate (common during competitive summer months), it reaches $2,500 per job. Exclusive leads close at 30–45%, reducing cost per acquired job to $400–$700 in most mid-size markets.
Why are shared HVAC leads particularly damaging during summer?
Summer AC demand spikes drive shared lead prices up while simultaneously flooding the market with competing contractors all calling the same homeowners. You pay more per lead during the weeks close rates are lowest — the worst possible economic combination.
How does exclusive HVAC lead generation change the revenue model?
Exclusive hub leasing converts lead acquisition from a variable per-job cost to a fixed monthly infrastructure expense. You own every HVAC inquiry in your city. At 30% close rate with 26 monthly leads, that is 7–8 jobs per month at a predictable acquisition cost regardless of seasonal demand spikes.
Are shared HVAC leads worth it?
At 8–18% close rate, shared HVAC leads cost $833–$3,875 per closed job in lead spend. On repair calls ($800–$1,800 tickets), the acquisition cost can exceed the job revenue. Exclusive hub leasing at 30–45% close rate brings cost per acquired HVAC job to $400–$700 — profitable across all job types, not just replacements.
Why do shared HVAC leads not convert?
Shared HVAC leads go to 3–5 contractors at once. The homeowner calls whoever answers fastest — not whoever does the best work. Emergency calls (your highest-close-rate job type) are especially damaged: a homeowner without AC in July cannot wait. On shared leads, 4 other HVAC contractors got that call at the same moment you did.
How many leads per month does a hvac hub generate?
A mid-size city hvac hub generates approximately 26 exclusive leads per month — 8 jobs × $7K avg = $52K/mo in potential revenue.
Why is exclusive better than shared?
Shared leads go to 3–5 contractors simultaneously. Exclusive hub leasing means every inquiry routes only to your business — no competition, 2–3× higher close rates.
How do I claim a hvac hub?
Browse available markets, select your city, and start your lease. One HVAC contractor per city at all times.
Own Your HVAC Market
Browse available hvac hubs. One HVAC contractor per city. Every lead exclusively yours from day one.
Browse Available HVAC Markets →